Yeah, Mall girl is 100x hotter than ES or the other one. I never found ES to be Hollywood hot. If she lived down the street, sure maybe, but you expect more from your "stars."
She had a short window where I thought she was hot.. but kind of the "cool sarcastic girl hot" than conventional.. but she almost fell all the way off the train recently it seems. Not sure if it's just age or bad plastic surgery or what.