CG: Mr. Clean v Oklahoma Don

[Monkeywrench]

don't forget to vote!

 

[DarkWynter]

Thoughts and commentary using the guidelines:
1. Custom quality
2. Bio/pics
3.Actual battle predictions
4.How many lasers/missiles the custom has
5.Is it a dinosaur?
6.Extras/presentation/special consideration

1--> Both are good, clean (pun intended) customs. Both have great accessories, but Damn do I love Mechs.
Verdict: Don
2--> Solid bios. Both bios were present, but the card was a nice touch.
Verdict: Slight edge Clean
3--> In a hand to hand brawl, it would be an even match. However, Don's Mech makes this a very one sided fight.
Verdict: Don
4--> Don's mech does have missiles!
Verdict: Don
5--> While both are not dinosaurs, one does have a Mech.
Verdict: Both fail.....but some awesome points for Don
6--> Mr. clean is a great custom, but I think you have seen a soft spot for mechs in my considerations so far. That said Mr. Clean earned himself a special consideration vote based on the humor and effort in the polling thread. Well played.
Verdict: Mr. Clean
Result: Don is taking this, is my favorite, and had the votes been closer would have my vote. I am however voting Mr.Clean to reflect a well played round.

 

[ska_lives]

Thoughts and commentary using the guidelines:
1. Custom quality
2. Bio/pics
3.Actual battle predictions
4.How many lasers/missiles the custom has
5.Is it a dinosaur?
6.Extras/presentation/special consideration

1--> Both are good, clean (pun intended) customs. Both have great accessories, but Damn do I love Mechs.
Verdict: Don
2--> Solid bios. Both bios were present, but the card was a nice touch.
Verdict: Slight edge Clean
3--> In a hand to hand brawl, it would be an even match. However, Don's Mech makes this a very one sided fight.
Verdict: Don
4--> Don's mech does have missiles!
Verdict: Don
5--> While both are not dinosaurs, one does have a Mech.
Verdict: Both fail.....but some awesome points for Don
6--> Mr. clean is a great custom, but I think you have seen a soft spot for mechs in my considerations so far. That said Mr. Clean earned himself a special consideration vote based on the humor and effort in the polling thread. Well played.
Verdict: Mr. Clean
Result: Don is taking this, is my favorite, and had the votes been closer would have my vote. I am however voting Mr.Clean to reflect a well played round.

I approve of your vote breakdown categories

 

[ian]

Thoughts and commentary using the guidelines:
1. Custom quality
2. Bio/pics
3.Actual battle predictions
4.How many lasers/missiles the custom has
5.Is it a dinosaur?
6.Extras/presentation/special consideration

1--> Both are good, clean (pun intended) customs. Both have great accessories, but Damn do I love Mechs.
Verdict: Don
2--> Solid bios. Both bios were present, but the card was a nice touch.
Verdict: Slight edge Clean
3--> In a hand to hand brawl, it would be an even match. However, Don's Mech makes this a very one sided fight.
Verdict: Don
4--> Don's mech does have missiles!
Verdict: Don
5--> While both are not dinosaurs, one does have a Mech.
Verdict: Both fail.....but some awesome points for Don
6--> Mr. clean is a great custom, but I think you have seen a soft spot for mechs in my considerations so far. That said Mr. Clean earned himself a special consideration vote based on the humor and effort in the polling thread. Well played.
Verdict: Mr. Clean
Result: Don is taking this, is my favorite, and had the votes been closer would have my vote. I am however voting Mr.Clean to reflect a well played round.

HAHAHA, man #5 is just great on every threads

 

[Monkeywrench]

Congrats Don!

 

[ian]

Nice job